Wiseacre Blawg

Legal and law articles. Law News. Blawg Links.

Price Discrimination

Very interesting post about price discrimination:

The WSJ had an article now about drug pricing and the power that big purchasers have with the drug manufacturers. The article got me thinking: Am I the only one who cares that small retail pharmacies (to the extent that they still exist) get the short end of the stick with drug manufacturers (or have historically, anyway)?

A nice example, albeit dated, deals with birth control pills. Most colleges sell to their students birth control pills at somewhere around $10 per package. The colleges get their birth control pills for perhaps $5 per package. The retail pharmacy on Main Street, however, gets the pills for $14 per package, and it sells for $19 to the person with insurance and $38 per package to the person without insurance. How is that fair? There is no way the retail pharmacy can ever compete with the University pharmacy (or the Wal-Mart pharmacy, that likely gets a equally significant discount).

The birth control pill manufacturers typically evade antitrust scrutiny b/c they maintain that they are giving the university a volume discount. Last I checked, however, most antitrust lawyers agreed that the true volume discount in situations like that was nowhere near the discounts universities, Wal-Marts, etc. were actually being given. The discounts given were far larger than the discounts that could be justified on a basis of costs saved due to volume purchases. Yet nobody squawks.

On a related note, why is it that I have to pay $75 for my doctors appointment if I miss it and dont call to cancel, but, if I had actually gone to the appointment, my insurer would have only been billed $48 or some such? I realize that my insurer has negotiated better prices with my doctor than have I, but why is that not price discrimination in violation of the Robinson-Patman Act? Where are our antitrust lawyers? I cannot believe that the volume discount math really works out in this case - my gut instinct is that the doctors are just caving to the insurers and sticking it to the poor individuals when insurance does not apply.

In my pursuit to be like Harvey Goldschmid, I have long wanted to teach antitrust, but Richmond could not really afford to have me give up a corporate class to teach antitrust. Hopefully, if I were teaching antitrust, I could answer my doctors appointment question myself.

Labels: , ,

Pathetic Legal Maze Hurting Parents & Children

Disclaimer: I, AM A LAWYER. The Information I have provided is based on my opinion and experience only. It is not be to taken or used as legal advice. It is purely for information to assist you in making informed decision. Please seek proper legal advice from a lawyer. Author of "Defending Our Lives" (Doubleday), and "Moving Out Moving On" when a relationship goes wrong.

I returned this morning from Chicago, still numb. I was asked to consult on a horrific case of a small child whose severe bruises and cries for help through our lovely and thoughtful court system have fallen on deaf ears. If your a parent or a family member of someone going through a nasty divorce or custody battle, I am asking that you pay close attention to this post.

I sat in a conference room watching a video tape of a small child. Happily playing about the house, that is until the doorbell rang. When the adult answered the door and the child sees who is there, piecing gut wrenching screams come out of this child in a way I have never heard before. "Please Mommy. Mommy. Don't let him take, please, please help, help it goes on and on for what felt like forever, it was hard for me to be composed as I watched a father take the child up over their shoulder and out to the car. This was not a child over reacting who didn't want to go with daddy. This is a child who feared for their safety, without exception. The tapes included two solid months of video visitation. On this last visit the child returned with severe bruises.

You would think the first immediate contact would be the Illinois Department of Children & Family Services, no it would not. The agency is overburdened, no excuse, but it is and in this case the child is too young to specifically give details upon this return visit or any other. Next step was a forensic child abuse specialist. Not a lot of those around and the waiting list for an appointment takes months. Throughout this ordeal the mother had been contacting the child's attorney referred to by the courts as a "guardian ad litem" a fee based attorney who is appointed by the courts to represent the best interests of the child or children in divorce cases. And the child's attorney never returns a single phone call to the mother during these two months. As an FYI, if the mother doesn't turn over a child where there is court ordered visitation, parent (any parent) will be in violation of that court order and arrested. Most, I did not say all are worthless, like a bad check. It took a lot of string pulling, the old, who you know, not what you know to get visitation temporally suspended. And in this case the child's lawyer had heard the phone messages and decided to sneak a motion in the back door to have another person pick up the child for visitation, this motion has now been overturned. And for the time being the father's visitation has been suspended, pending further investigation. I don't know how much investigation is required when you have such strong evidence, but at least he can't see the child, for now anyway. The child's attorney was just trying to save his sorry butt, instead of protecting the minor child.

This is just one single case out of hundred's of thousands that take place in divorce courts across the country.

If you think the legal system is broken, it is not. The crime takes place with the parties who represent the parents and the children. Yes, I realize there are disciplinary systems in place to deal with incompetent lawyers, but a system such as this is very poor at policing and monitoring themselves throughout the country.

In a divorce where their are children, the first priority should be the welfare of the wee ones. Case after case, clearly that is not happening and it is getting worse. Over all the country.

Some things you can do:

No matter what your attorney says, make sure you are at each court appearance, even when they tell you it's just a status hearing. Your paying for them to represent your not paying for shuffle and lip service that does not represent your best interests.

Create a phone log with a time and date of everyone your leaving message as it pertains to your divorce or custody case and what you said. A simple idea would be to create a log on your computer email it to yourself and then print it off. This is important, it will show the dates and times of each one your printing off.

If you suspect child abuse, contact your lawyer first, explain what you believe is happening. If you feel your not getting anywhere, take the child to your family doctor, or call around to hospitals and ask for a doctor who specializes in abuse cases, if possible. If there are marks on the child take pictures and or use a video camera. Your cell phone may also take pictures consider using that and emailing to your computer. It's also very important to remain as calm as possible, be patient during this process.

Do not take matters into your own hands and stop visitation let the professionals handle the alleged allegations.

If your lawyer is not addressing your needs, not responding or representing you properly, look and interview for a new attorney.

Do not be afraid of the legal system.

Do not let your attorney bargain out your life, it may not be in your best interest, only in theirs, as is with many cases.

I take a big risk in even glossing over this subject. I have committed a legal taboo. I do so only for the sake and safety of the children.
Disclaimer: I, AM A LAWYER. The Information I have provided is based on my opinion and experience only. It is not be to taken or used as legal advice. It is purely for information to assist you in making informed decision. Please seek proper legal advice from a lawyer. Author of "Defending Our Lives" (Doubleday), and "Moving Out Moving On" when a relationship goes wrong.